A federal judge in Mobile has declined to award qualified immunity to Baldwin County Sheriff Huey “Hoss” Mack and Deputy Matt Hunady, defendants in a civil lawsuit filed by the mother of Jonathan Victor, a 35-year-old unarmed motorist who was shot and killed by Hunady after a single-vehicle accident on Interstate 10 in May 2017.
In an order filed April 19, U.S. District Court Judge William Cassady dismissed a single claim against Mack, but denied to grant the defendants’ broader motion for summary judgment. Reviewed “in a light most favorable to the plaintiff,” Cassady wrote, videotapes, audio, and witness statements from the incident leave cause to believe a jury could find that Hunady violated Victor’s constitutional rights, while Mack failed to adequately train his deputies to respond to mental health crises.
kAmp44@C5:?8 E@ E96 C64@C5[ G@=F?E66C 7:C67:89E6CD H6C6 :?:E:2==J 42==65 E@ E96 D46?6 @7 E96 244:56?E 27E6C 2 H:E?6DD ?@E:465 ':4E@C’D G69:4=6 DEF4< :? E96 >F55J >65:2? @7 x\`_ E9C@H:?8 FA 2 “C@@DE6C E2:=” @7 >F5] %96 H:E?6DD 42==65 h`` 27E6C 2EE6>AE:?8 E@ 2DD:DE ':4E@C[ 3FE 36:?8 E@=5 3J ':4E@C E@ 8@ 2H2J] %96 H:E?6DD D2:5 ':4E@C H2D 3=@@5J 2?5 “>2J 92G6” 366? 2C>65 H:E9 2 H62A@?]k^Am
kAmu2465 H:E9 E96 D2>6 =24< @7 4@@A6C2E:@? 2?5 4@?46C?D FA@? E96:C 2CC:G2=[ C6DA@?5:?8 7:C67:89E6CD 42==65 7@C 2DD:DE2?46 7C@> E96 q2=5H:? r@F?EJ $96C:77’D ~77:46 Wqr$~X] #25:@ 4@>>F?:42E:@? :?5:42E65 ':4E@C H2D “A@DD:3=J 2C>65[” 2?5 H96? wF?25J 2CC:G65[ 96 :>>65:2E6=J 2C>65 9:>D6=7 H:E9 9:D D6CG:46 C:7=6 2?5 E@@< 2 5676?D:G6 A@D:E:@? 369:?5 2 7:C6 ECF4<[ D@>6 b_ 766E 7C@> ':4E@C’D G69:4=6]k^Am
kAmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^=28?:2AA6>@3:=6]4@>^G:56@D\42AEFC6\4@?7FD:@?\=625:?8\E@\5625=J\D9@@E:?8\@7\;@?2E92?\G:4E@C^Q C6=lQ?@@A6?6CQ E2C86ElQ03=2?<Qm':56@E2A6 6I4=FD:G6=J @3E2:?65 3J {28?:2AAk^2m6 5FC:?8 E96 4@FCD6 @7 E96 =2HDF:E D9@HD E92E 7@C E96 ?6IE `_ >:?FE6D[ wF?25J 96=5 9:D A@D:E:@? 2?5 2EE6>AE65 E@ 6DE23=:D9 4@>>F?:42E:@? H:E9 ':4E@C[ 3FE 5:5 ?@E 7FCE96C :?G6DE:82E6 E96 4:C4F>DE2?46D @7 E96 244:56?E @C ':4E@C’D 3692G:@C] u:CDE C6DA@?56CD 925 2=D@ 6DE23=:D965 — :?7@C>2E:@? E92E H2D 2=D@ C6=2J65 E@ wF?25J — E92E ':4E@C H2D “24E:?8 6CC2E:42==J” 2?5 “925 D@>6E9:?8 :? 9:D 92?5D]”k^Am
kAm(92E 92AA6?65 27E6C ':4E@C DE6AA65 @FE @7 E96 G69:4=6 “:D 2 D@FC46 @7 AC@7@F?5 5:D28C66>6?E” :? E96 4@FCE C64@C5[ r2DD25J 7@F?5[ ?@E:?8 wF?25J 2?5 @E96C 7:CDE C6DA@?56CD 4=2:>65 ':4E@C DF556?=J 6>6C865 7C@> 9:D G69:4=6 2?5 E@@< 2? “288C6DD:G6 D9@@E6C’D DE2?46]” qFE r2DD25J 56E6C>:?65 E96 G:56@ C64@C5:?8D “42? 36 C62D@?23=J 4@?DECF65 2D A@CEC2J:?8 ':4E@C’D 24E:@?D 27E6C 6I:E:?8 E96 G69:4=6 BF:E6 5:776C6?E=J E92? E96 288C6DD:G6 D9@@E:?8 DE2?46 E92E s6AFEJ wF?25J 2D4C:36D E@ 9:>]”k^Am
kAmr2DD25J D2:5 E@ E96 4@?EC2CJ[ wF?25J’D 52D9 42> G:56@ D9@HD ':4E@C 2D “F?DE625J” @? 9:D 766E] w:D 92?5D H6C6 ?@E “AF?4965 @FE” :? 7C@?E @7 9:>[ 3FE C2E96C “?62C 9:D 7246]” r2DD25J 6>A92D:K65 E92E 2 “C62D@?23=6 7:?56C @7 724E 4@F=5 4@?4=F56 7C@> E9:D G:56@ E92E ':4E@C 5:5 ?@E E2<6 288C6DD:G6 24E:@? E@H2C5 s6AFEJ wF?25J @C 2?J@?6 6=D6[ 2?5 E92E 96 5:5 ?@E AF?49 @FE 9:D 2C>D :? 2 D9@@E6C DE2?46]”k^Am
kAmp=E9@F89 wF?25J 925 366? EC2:?65 @? E96 FD6 @7 5625=J 7@C46[ E96 @C56C 2=D@ 7@F?5 E96 qr$~ “5:5 ?@E 92G6 @77:46C EC2:?:?8 AC@8C2>D 7@C 4C:D:D :?E6CG6?E:@?[ 56\6D42=2E:@?[ @C 7@C 562=:?8 H:E9 A6CD@?D H9@ 2C6 DF:4:52= @C @E96CH:D6 F?56C 24FE6 >6?E2= 5:DEC6DD]”k^Am
k9C ^m
k9C ^m
kAm%96 5676?52?ED D@F89E 5:D>:DD2= @? E96 8C@F?5D @7 BF2=:7:65 :>>F?:EJ[ H9:49 “@776CD 4@>A=6E6 AC@E64E:@? 7@C 8@G6C?>6?E @77:4:2=D DF65 :? E96:C :?5:G:5F2= 42A24:E:6D 2D =@?8 2D E96:C 4@?5F4E G:@=2E6D ?@ 4=62C=J 6DE23=:D965 DE2EFE@CJ @? 4@?DE:EFE:@?2= C:89ED]” %96C6 H2D ?@ 5:DAFE6 E92E wF?25J H2D 24E:?8 H:E9:? 9:D DE2EFE@CJ 2FE9@C:EJ[ D@ E96 3FC56? H2D @? E96 A=2:?E:77 E@ 56>@?DEC2E6 wF?25J G:@=2E65 2 4@?DE:EFE:@?2= C:89E @7 ':4E@C’D 2?5 E96 C:89E H2D “4=62C=J 6DE23=:D965 2E E96 E:>6 @7 E96 2==6865 G:@=2E:@?]”k^Am
kAmr2DD25J 7@F?5 E96 C6=6G2?E 724ED :?4=F565ik^Am
kAm• }@ H:E?6DD 925 C6A@CE65 E@ s6AFEJ wF?25J[ 6:E96C 5:C64E=J @C :?5:C64E=J[ E92E ':4E@C H2D 2C>65[ @?=J E92E 96 H2D “A@DD:3=J” 2C>65]k^Am
kAm• s6AFEJ wF?25J ?6G6C 2EE6>AE65 E@ 7@==@H FA H:E9 2?J @7 E96 3JDE2?56CD[ 7:CDE C6DA@?56CD @C ':4E@C 9:>D6=7 E@ 2D46CE2:? H96E96C ':4E@C 925 2 H62A@?]k^Am
kAm• (96? ':4E@C 7:?2==J DE6AA65 @FE @7 E96 42C[ 2 C62D@?23=6 724E 7:?56C 4@F=5 4@?4=F56 E92E 96 H2D ?6:E96C 288C6DD:G6 ?@C E9C62E6?:?8 E@ s6AFEJ wF?25J @C 2?J@?6 6=D6]k^Am
kAm• ':56@ 7@@E286 D9@HD ':4E@C E2<:?8 D=@H[ 96D:E2?E[ 92=E:?8 DE6AD :? E96 >F55J 8C2DD @7 E96 >65:2?[ 2== @7 H9:49 :D 4@?D:DE6?E H:E9 D@>6@?6 H9@ 92D 366? :?;FC65 :? 2? 2FE@>@3:=6 244:56?E]k^Am
kAm• ':4E@C >256 ?@ E9C62E6?:?8 DE2E6>6?ED]k^Am
kAm• ':4E@C 2AA62C65 E@ 9@=5 2? F?:56?E:7:65 @3;64E HC2AA65 :? 2 4=@E9 :? 9:D 92?5[ H9:49 96 5:5 ?@E C6=:?BF:D9 56DA:E6 s6AFEJ wF?25J’D 4@>>2?5D E@ “5C@A :E]” qFE E96C6 H2D ?@ A2CE:4F=2C C62D@? E@ 36=:6G6 E96 4=@E9\HC2AA65 @3;64E H2D 2 7:C62C>] p C62D@?23=6 7:?56C @7 724E 4@F=5 4@?4=F56 7C@> E96 6G:56?46 E92E :E 5:5 ?@E =@@< =:<6 2 H62A@? 2?5 E92E ':4E@C H2D ?@E 3C2?5:D9:?8 2?JE9:?8 :? 2? 288C6DD:G6 @C E9C62E6?:?8 >2??6C]k^Am
kAm“s6AFEJ wF?25J’D 2DD6CE:@? E92E 96 D9@E ':4E@C 3642FD6 96 762C65 7@C 9:D @H? =:76 2D H6== 2D E96 =:G6D 2?5 D276EJ @7 @E96C @77:46CD[ 7:CDE C6DA@?56CD 2?5 >6>36CD @7 E96 AF3=:4 :D @?6 E92E 2 C62D@?23=6 ;FCJ 4@F=5 C6;64E[” r2DD25J HC@E6] “p7E6C 2==[ s6AFEJ wF?25J 2?5 9:D 4@==628F6D H6C6 ?@E DE2?5:?8 @FE :? E96 @A6?[ 3FE :?DE625 925 E2<6? 4@G6C 369:?5 2 7:C6 ECF4<] x? E96 =:89E >@DE 72G@C23=6 E@ E96 A=2:?E:77[ E96 C64@C5 D9@HD E92E ':4E@C H2D ?@E 288C6DD:G6[ H2D ?@E 25G2?4:?8 2E E96 E:>6 @7 E96 D9@@E:?8[ H2D DE2?5:?8 DE:== 2AAC@I:>2E6=J a_ 766E 7C@> s6AFEJ wF?25J[ 2?5 2AA62C65 5:D@C:6?E65 @C :? D9@4< 7C@> E96 244:56?E] xE :D 2=D@ D:8?:7:42?E E92E ':4E@C H2D H:E9:? C2?86 @7 s6AFEJ wF?25J’D %2D6C[ H9:49 96 925 @? 9:D A6CD@? 2?5 2G2:=23=6 E@ 56A=@J 2E 2?J E:>6 925 96 6=64E65 E@ 5@ D@] p?@E96C C6=6G2?E 4@?D:56C2E:@? :D E92E 5FC:?8 E96 6?E:C6 E:>6 E92E E96J D9@FE65 4@>>2?5D 2E ':4E@C 7C@> 369:?5 E96 D276EJ @7 E96 7:C6 ECF4<[ ?6:E96C s6AFEJ wF?25J ?@C 2?J @E96C @77:46C @? E96 D46?6 6G6C H2C?65 E@ ':4E@C E92E 96 H@F=5 36 D9@E :7 96 72:=65 E@ 4@>A=J H:E9 4@>>2?5D E@ ‘5C@A :E[’ ‘DE@A 25G2?4:?8[’ 2?5 E96 =:<6]”k^Am
kAmr@FA=65 H:E9 2 72:=FC6 E@ :?G6DE:82E6 H96E96C ':4E@C H2D 24EF2==J 2C>65 E9C@F89@FE E96 6?E:C6 `d\>:?FE6 DE2?5@77 2?5 E96 <?@H=6586 ':4E@C 925 ?@E 4@>>:EE65 2?J <?@H? @776?D6D AC:@C E@ E96 D9@@E:?8[ r2DD25J F=E:>2E6=J 56E6C>:?65 “2 C62D@?23=6 ;FCJ 4@F=5 4@?4=F56[ H:E9@FE CF??:?8 27@F= @7 E96 ;F5:4:2= 5676C6?46 A2:5 E@ A@=:46 @77:46CD >2<:?8 DA=:E\D64@?5 564:D:@?D :? 52?86C@FD D:EF2E:@?D[ E92E s6AFEJ wF?25J >:D>2?2865 E9@D6 6=6>6?ED 2?5 G:@=2E65 ':4E@C’D u@FCE9 p>6?5>6?E C:89ED 3J F?C62D@?23=J FD:?8 5625=J 7@C46 E@ DF35F6 9:> :? 2 D:EF2E:@? E92E A@D65 ?@ :>>:?6?E E9C62E]”k^Am
kAm“s6AFEJ wF?25J 925 2>A=6 E:>6 @? E96 D46?6 367@C6 E96 4@?7C@?E2E:@? E@ >2CD92= C6D@FC46D 2?5 56G:D6 4@?E:?86?4:6D E@ AC6D6CG6 =:76 2?5 >2I:>:K6 D276EJ 7@C 6G6CJ@?6 :?G@=G65[” r2DD25J 6IA=2:?65] “w6 925 >@C6 E92? E6? >:?FE6D @? E96 D46?6 E@ 7@C>F=2E6 A=2?D 2?5 >2<6 2CC2?86>6?ED E@ D2768F2C5 E96 =:G6D @7 6G6CJ@?6 :?G@=G65] p=E9@F89 5676?52?ED AC@E6DE E92E ‘':4E@C 4@?EC@==65 E96 6?E:C6 D46?6[’ 2 ;FCJ 4@F=5 4@?4=F56 E92E :D D:>A=J ?@E ECF6] x?5665[ :E H@F=5 36 C62D@?23=6 @? E9:D C64@C5 E@ 7:?5 E92E s6AFEJ wF?25J 4@?EC@==65 E96 D46?6 3J 4@?E:?F2==J 4@>>2?5:?8 ':4E@C E@ DE6A @FE @7 E96 G69:4=6[ C2E96C E92? 2==@H:?8 9:> E@ C6>2:? E96C6 F?E:= >@C6 96=A W2?5 2AAC@AC:2E6 DA64:2=:K65 C6D@FC46DX 4@F=5 36 42==65]k^Am
kAm“s6AFEJ wF?25J 925 E:>6 E@ A=2? 7@C H92E H@F=5 92AA6? :7 2?5 H96? ':4E@C 5:5 6I:E E96 G69:4=6 2?5 3692G65 6CC2E:42==J WH9:49 H2D 6?E:C6=J 7@C6D6623=6 8:G6? E96 C6A@CED @7 9:D 6CC2E:4 3692G:@C :?D:56 E96 G69:4=6 367@C6 s6AFEJ wF?25J 2CC:G65 @? E96 D46?6X[” r2DD25J HC@E6] “w6 925 E:>6 E@ >2<6 2CC2?86>6?ED 7@C E96 D276EJ @7 =2H 6?7@C46>6?E[ 7:CDE C6DA@?56CD 2?5 >6>36CD @7 E96 AF3=:4] w6 925 E:>6 E@ DA62< H:E9 H:E?6DD6D E@ 56E6C>:?6 H92E[ 6I24E=J[ E96J 925 D66? E92E >:89E ‘A@DD:3=J’ 92G6 366? 2 8F? H96? E96J :?E6C24E65 H:E9 ':4E@C] w6 925 E:>6 E@ 4@?D:56C ?@?\=6E92= 7@C46 @AE:@?D[ DF49 2D E96 %2D6C 96 H2D 42CCJ:?8 @? 9:D A6CD@?] w6 925 E:>6 E@ 4@?D:56C 42==:?8 :? E96 qr$~’D ?68@E:2E:@? E62>] p== @7 E96D6 6=6>6?ED H6C6 H:E9:? s6AFEJ wF?25J’D 4@?EC@=[ ?@E ':4E@C’D]”k^Am
kAm$:>:=2C=J[ 6G6? E9@F89 |24< H2D ?@E 5:C64E=J :?G@=G65 :? E96 D9@@E:?8[ r2DD25J 56E6C>:?65 9:D =:23:=:EJ >2J 36 6IA@D65 3J “2 42FD2= 4@??64E:@? 36EH66? E96 24E:@?D @7 E96 DFA6CG:D:?8 @77:4:2= 2?5 E96 2==6865 4@?DE:EFE:@?2= 56AC:G2E:@?]” q642FD6 qr$~ 5:5 ?@E @776C 4C:D:D :?E6CG6?E:@? EC2:?:?8 2E E96 E:>6 @7 E96 :?4:56?E[ E96 A=2:?E:77 2C8F6D |24< D9@H65 “56=:36C2E6 :?5:776C6?46” E@ ':4E@C’D 4@?DE:EFE:@?2= C:89ED] qFE E96 5676?52?ED 2C8F65 |24< H2D 6?E:E=65 E@ BF2=:7:65 :>>F?:EJ “3642FD6 E96C6 :D ?@ 6G:56?46 @7 2?J DF49 A2EE6C? @7 >:D4@?5F4E[ H9:49 :D 2 ?646DD2CJ AC64@?5:E:@? 7@C 2 7:?5:?8 @7 56=:36C2E6 :?5:776C6?46]”k^Am
kAmqFE[ “A=2:?E:77D’ 6G:56?46 :D E92E 4:C4F>DE2?46D =:<6 ':4E@C’D 2C6 3@E9 4@>>@? 2?5 C64FCC:?8 :? =2H 6?7@C46>6?E @77:46CD’ 52:=J 24E:G:E:6D[ 2?5 E92E E96C6 :D 2? @3G:@FD A@E6?E:2= 7@C 2 DF3;64E’D 7656C2= C:89ED E@ 36 G:@=2E65 :? E92E D:EF2E:@?[” r2DD25J 7@F?5] “x?5665[ A=2:?E:77D’ 6IA6CE @A:?6D E92E E96C6 H6C6 2D >2?J 2D `[___ @77:46C\:?G@=G65 D9@@E:?8D 5FC:?8 E96 a_`d\a_`g A6C:@5 :?G@=G:?8 4:C4F>DE2?46D DF49 2D ':4E@C’D[ H96C6 E96 DF3;64E 2AA62C65 E@ 36 :? 2 >6?E2= 962=E9 4C:D:D[ H2D ?@E 3692G:?8 =:<6 2 4C:>:?2= @776?56C[ 6I9:3:E65 288C6DD:G6 @C DEC2?86 3692G:@C[ 2?5 H2D F?2C>65] pAAC@I:>2E6=J ah A6C46?E @7 @77:46C\:?G@=G65 D9@@E:?8D :?G@=G6 E96D6 C64@8?:K65 4:C4F>DE2?46D] pD DF49[ A=2:?E:77 92D >256 2? 256BF2E6 D9@H:?8 E92E E9:D :D E96 <:?5 @7 C64FCC:?8 D:EF2E:@? AC6D6?E:?8 2? @3G:@FD[ 9:89=J AC65:4E23=6 A@E6?E:2= 7@C G:@=2E:@? E92E 42? EC:886C =:23:=:EJ 7@C 72:=FC6 E@ EC2:?[ 6G6? :? E96 23D6?46 @7 2 A2EE6C? @7 G:@=2E:@?D]”k^Am
kAm|62?H9:=6[ r2DD25J 5:D>:DD65 E96 A=2:?E:77’D “|@?6== =:23:=:EJ” 4=2:> 282:?DE |24<[ 3642FD6 |24< 2?5 wF?25J 2C6 36:?8 DF65 :? E96:C :?5:G:5F2= 42A24:E:6D[ 2?5 ?@ >F?:4:A2= 6?E:EJ 92D 366? ?2>65 2D 2 5676?52?E]k^Am
kAm~? pAC:= `[ 2 HC@?87F= 562E9 =2HDF:E k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^=28?:2AA6>@3:=6]4@>^HC@?87F=\562E9\=2HDF:E\7:=65\:?\72E2=\34D@\G69:4=6\AFCDF:E^Q C6=lQ?@@A6?6CQ E2C86ElQ03=2?<QmH2D 7:=65 :? 4:C4F:E 4@FCEk^2m 282:?DE |24<[ {@I=6J A@=:46 @77:46C $E6A96? q2:=6J 2?5 E96 E@H? @7 {@I=6J 7@C 2 5625=J 9:89\DA665[ HC@?8\H2J AFCDF:E E92E <:==65 2 72E96C[ 9:D D@?[ 2?5 E9C66 @E96C :?5:G:5F2=D :? E96 42C E92E H2D 36:?8 492D65] {2DE J62C[ E96 52F89E6C @7 2 u2:C9@A6 >2? H9@ H2D <:==65 :? 2 D9@@E@FE H:E9 E96 qr$~ 5FC:?8 2? 6G:4E:@? AC@46DD k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^=28?:2AA6>@3:=6]4@>^=2HDF:E\7:=65\282:?DE\32=5H:?\4@F?EJ\56AFE:6D\@G6C\5625=J\a_`g\6G:4E:@?^Q C6=lQ?@@A6?6CQ E2C86ElQ03=2?<Qm7:=65 2 7656C2= =2HDF:Ek^2m 282:?DE |24< 2?5 @E96C 56AFE:6D[ 2==68:?8 4@?DE:EFE:@?2= G:@=2E:@?D[ ?68=:86?46[ 6I46DD:G6 7@C46 2?5 56=:36C2E6 :?5:776C6?46 E@ 96C 72E96C’D D276EJ 2?5 >65:42= ?665D[ 2?5 @E96C 4@F?ED] %96 A=2:?E:77 :D 36:?8 C6AC6D6?E65 3J 2 ?6H 2EE@C?6J H9@ C646?E=J 7:=65 2? 2>6?565 4@>A=2:?E]k^Am
kAmx? |@3:=6 r@F?EJ[ 7@C>6C |@3:=6 !@=:46 @77:46C w2C@=5 wFCDE k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^=28?:2AA6>@3:=6]4@>^>@E96C\@7\>:4926=\>@@C6\D6EE=6D\:?\4@FCE\@G6C\D@?D\562E9\3J\>A5\@77:46C^Q C6=lQ?@@A6?6CQ E2C86ElQ03=2?<QmC646?E=J C624965 2 Sa]d >:==:@? D6EE=6>6?Ek^2m H:E9 E96 >@E96C @7 |:4926= |@@C6[ 2 `h\J62C\@=5 D9@E 2?5 <:==65 5FC:?8 2 EC277:4 DE@A :? a_`e] %96 D6EE=6>6?E H2D ?68@E:2E65 27E6C &]$] s:DEC:4E yF586 %6CCJ |@@C6C CF=65 :? $6AE6>36C E92E wFCDE H2D ?@E AC@E64E65 3J BF2=:7:65 :>>F?:EJ] }@ 4C:>:?2= 492C86D H6C6 7:=65 :? 2?J @7 E96 42D6D]k^Am
(0) comments
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.